The world of work is transforming, accelerated by technological advancements and unexpected global challenges. Traditional performance management systems, once the backbone of organizational assessment and improvement, are now being scrutinized for their relevance and effectiveness in this new era. The need for a reimagined approach to performance management has never been more pressing, echoing the sentiments of thought leaders like M. Tamra Chandler, who has been at the forefront of advocating for change in this domain.
Chandler, a seasoned consultant and author, has long criticized traditional performance management for its one-dimensional and backward-looking nature. Her acclaimed works, including How Performance Management is Killing Performance – and What to Do About It, provide a robust critique and a roadmap for organizations seeking to breathe new life into their performance management practices. Chandler’s insights are based on her extensive experience in partnering with organizations across various industries, aiming to foster environments where people can truly thrive.
One of the core issues with traditional performance management, as Chandler points out, is its focus on ratings and annual reviews, which often fail to reflect the dynamic nature of work and the diverse capabilities of employees. The data supports this critique, with studies from entities like Gartner revealing that a significant portion of leaders worldwide is dissatisfied with current performance management outcomes, signaling a disconnect between these outdated practices and the evolving needs of businesses and their workforce.
“We were tasked us with exploring how Performance Management impacts performance. Surprisingly, our findings indicated a stark absence of evidence supporting its effectiveness. In fact, we frequently discovered that traditional Performance Management practices were more likely to foster disengagement rather than enhance performance.”
Tamra chandler
In response to these challenges, Chandler advocates for a more nuanced, flexible, and human-centric approach. Modern performance management, she argues, should prioritize growth and development over mere performance evaluation. This shift requires a fundamental change in mindset—from assessing to empowering, from rating to nurturing. It’s about creating a culture where feedback is constructive, continuous, and centered on development, enabling individuals and teams to excel.
The advent of the pandemic has further highlighted the limitations of traditional performance management systems. The shift to remote work underscored the necessity for practices that are adaptable and inclusive, capable of fostering connection and collaboration even in the absence of physical proximity. Chandler sees this as an opportunity to accelerate the transition towards more effective, equitable, and responsive performance management practices.
A key aspect of modernizing performance management is addressing the issue of fairness and eliminating bias. Chandler emphasizes the importance of incorporating multiple perspectives in performance assessments and making the process as transparent and inclusive as possible. This approach not only enhances trust and accountability but also contributes to a more equitable workplace where diversity is valued and leveraged for organizational success.
Furthermore, Chandler suggests that organizations should move away from rigid, one-size-fits-all solutions and embrace a more customizable framework that acknowledges the unique contributions of each employee. This entails rethinking how goals are set, how feedback is delivered, and how achievements are recognized and rewarded. It’s about aligning individual growth with organizational objectives, creating a symbiotic relationship that drives mutual advancement.
In essence, modern performance management is an ongoing, dynamic process that champions growth, teamwork, and adaptability. It demands a departure from conventional practices and a commitment to fostering an environment where every employee has the opportunity to learn, contribute, and excel. Organizations willing to embark on this journey, guided by insights from leaders like Tamra Chandler, will not only enhance their performance management outcomes but also build a more resilient, engaged, and future-ready workforce.
Meet Tamra Chandler at The HR Congress WorldSummit in Porto on May 14-15 where she will deliver a captivating keynote address and an in-depth Masterclass.
